Go to main text
Structures Material Structures Material

Enamel Steel Fish Scaling: Why the Coating Chips After Firing

MindCore Reading time 18min

A smooth enamel finish can pass an initial inspection and develop small, scale-like chips later. When that happens, the useful question is not simply whether the coating looked good at the furnace exit. It is what changed between firing, cooling, and the appearance of the damage.

Enamel steel fish scaling is a hydrogen-related coating defect that can develop after firing and cooling. This article concerns fired porcelain or vitreous enamel on steel, not paint sold as “enamel.” It explains the mechanism and offers a practical framework for investigating a suspect batch.

What Causes Fish Scaling in Enamel Steel?

During firing, hydrogen can enter the hot steel. As the steel cools, its hydrogen solubility falls. Hydrogen moving toward the steel–enamel interface can accumulate as gas beneath the solidified coating. Local pressure can then break away small pieces of enamel.

The damage can appear after a variable delay. ArcelorMittal identifies a moist firing atmosphere, inadequate drying of wet-applied enamel, and unsuitable steel as factors that aggravate the problem. A clean appearance immediately after firing therefore does not settle the investigation. [1]

Why the Steel Matters as Much as the Coating

Enameling-grade sheet is engineered for more than formability. Nippon Steel identifies coating adhesion, finish quality, and fishscaling resistance as additional material requirements. Its manufacturing description links performance to steel chemistry and controlled thermal processing. [2]

Hydrogen storage or trapping within a suitable steel can reduce harmful accumulation beneath the coating. This is why replacing a sheet with another material of the same thickness and similar strength is not enough to establish equivalent enameling performance.

Nor is titanium content a simple pass/fail shortcut. Tata Steel, for example, describes titanium-free Vitrostaal LD grades with improved fishscaling resistance. The purchasing question should be whether the specific grade is suitable for the intended enameling route—not whether its chemistry contains one favored element. [3]

What Research Adds to the Explanation

In a study of one ultra-low-carbon enameling steel, Liu and colleagues found that changes in continuous-annealing soaking temperature altered grain size, precipitates, and measured hydrogen-permeation behavior. Fishscaling resistance declined as the studied microstructure changed. These were steel-processing conditions, not recommended enamel-furnace settings. [4]

A separate study by Lin and colleagues examined two enameled ultra-low-carbon steels and emphasized hydrogen trapping by bubbles near the steel–enamel interface. It also reported limitations in relating conventional permeation measurements to actual fishscaling for some steels. [5]

Together, these findings support evaluating the actual material and coating system. They do not establish one universal trapping mechanism or a chemistry-only guarantee.

A Practical Investigation: Record the Sequence First

The following is a suggested troubleshooting record, not a formal acceptance test. Its purpose is to make a discussion with the steel supplier and enamel supplier more productive.

  1. Record when the damage first appeared. Separate observations made after cooling, after handling, and after storage. Photograph the same identified locations at each inspection.
  2. Preserve material traceability. Record the coil or heat reference, steel grade, thickness, and affected part numbers. Keep unaffected comparison pieces identifiable too.
  3. Record the coating route. Note the enamel batch, pretreatment, application method, drying records, and firing history. Identify changes from the last satisfactory batch.
  4. Describe the pattern without diagnosing it prematurely. Note whether chips concentrate at contact points, edges, or other locations. Record known impacts and handling events.
  5. Agree on the next test. Ask which specimens, observation period, and evaluation method are appropriate for this grade and enamel system.

A photograph of a chip is useful evidence, but it does not establish hydrogen as the cause. Keep the observation—“coating chipped after cooling”—separate from the proposed explanation—“suspected fishscaling.”

Example: A Different Coil and a Changed Drying Cycle

Hypothetical troubleshooting example: A manufacturer changes steel coils and shortens the drying cycle during the same production shift. The finished panels initially look acceptable, but chips appear during subsequent storage.

Blaming the new coil immediately would overlook the process change. Blaming drying alone would overlook the material change. Two variables moved together, so the batch does not isolate either explanation.

A useful comparison plan would retain the approved steel and process as a baseline, then evaluate the proposed changes separately under supplier-agreed conditions. Keep the enamel batch, part geometry, identification, and inspection method consistent wherever practical.

The important result is a traceable comparison. If the trial still changes several conditions at once, it may reproduce the defect without explaining it.

How to Reduce Fishscaling Risk

Start with a steel grade qualified for the intended enameling process. Maintain the specified drying and firing conditions, and investigate moisture-related departures rather than assuming a visually dry surface proves the process was satisfactory. These actions address the material and process factors identified in the producer guidance. [1]

For a proposed production change, ask the suppliers to document:

  • The approved steel grade and compatible coating route.
  • The process conditions that must remain controlled.
  • The applicable fishscaling evaluation and acceptance criteria.
  • The records required before a trial batch is released.

A general article cannot supply a universally safe firing temperature, drying time, or inspection delay. Those values need to come from the qualified system and its agreed quality procedure.

Hydrogen Permeation Tests and Enameling Tests

Testing should match the question being asked. A hydrogen-permeation result characterizes behavior under a specified test method; an enameling test evaluates susceptibility under a defined coating and firing procedure.

The European Enamel Association’s Quality Requirements, Edition 5.0 treats hydrogen permeability and fishscaling resistance as separate test topics. Its fishscaling procedure uses a sensitive enamel and calls for the frit supplier to specify coating thickness and thermal conditions. [6]

When comparing reports, ask whether the steel type, specimen condition, test method, and acceptance basis are compatible. A number without its method and applicability is not a complete qualification.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does fish scaling mean the steel is rusting?

The term describes hydrogen-related enamel damage. A corrosion investigation is a separate question; do not diagnose either condition from the word “scaling” alone.

Can changing steel thickness solve it?

Thickness alone does not qualify a replacement. Ask for evidence that the proposed material and enameling process work together.

What information should accompany a supplier complaint?

Send identifiable photographs, the defect timeline, material and enamel batch references, process records, and a description of any changes. State what was observed and what remains unconfirmed.

Technical References

  1. ArcelorMittal, Steel for enamelling and enamelled steel: User manual, Section 4.1, “Hydrogen and ‘fish scales.’” Online version consulted November 18, 2026.
  2. Nippon Steel, Steel Sheets for Vitreous Enameling, catalog U046en, manufacturing and product-performance sections.
  3. Tata Steel, Vitrostaal for Enamelling, product overview.
  4. Liu, Z., Kang, Y., and Li, Y. (2019), Influence of continuous annealing soaking temperature on fish-scaling resistance of ultra-low carbon steel for porcelain enameling, Metallurgical Research & Technology, 116, 205.
  5. Lin, Y.-T., et al. (2020), New approaches in understanding the effects of hydrogen trapping and the fishscaling resistance of enameled steels, Surface and Coatings Technology, article 126135.
  6. European Enamel Association, Quality Requirements, Edition 5.0 (2020), Sections 4.16 and 4.22. Consult the applicable current standard and agreed product requirements when specifying tests.

MindCore

Related Articles

광고 차단 알림

광고 클릭 제한을 초과하여 광고가 차단되었습니다.

단시간에 반복적인 광고 클릭은 시스템에 의해 감지되며, IP가 수집되어 사이트 관리자가 확인 가능합니다.